The Truth About Forever

The Truth About Forever The Truth About Forever by Sarah Dessen
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

At the start of this this enjoyable first-person narrative, Macy aims to be perfect. She doesn't want to rock the boat; her father's recent unexpected death has shaken her family enough. Told over the time period of a summer break, Macy is a clear example of a character that shows growth. Macy begins her summer with a perfect boyfriend, a college-application-worthy job, and dedication to her SAT studies. Though following a prescribed course, Macy isn't happy, though she doesn't realize this at first. When Macy meets Delia and her catering staff at one of her mother's events, Macy begins to crave change and joy in her life. Through her newfound friendships, Macy explores what she really wants in her life and she finds it's not always the expected.

I struggle to put limits on the intended audiences of books. Sarah Dessen is an author of books for anyone who wishes to read them, not specifically a book for girls/women. Though this book's main character is a young adult female, this is a young adult book, period. However, I will say this book has been marketed to a female audience. The cover shown here shows a bright pink flower; the cover of the copy I read features a turquoise bracelet. I took several classes on young adult and children's literature in grad school (I'm a librarian AND a trained as a high school English teacher!). We were taught that boys prefer books with a male protagonist and that girls will generally read anything. While this might hold some truth, to assume this about every young adult/teen is not fair to readers. I am interested in what more "seasoned" YA librarians think, as well as what actual young adults think. Is it appropriate to assign gender-based audiences to young adult literature?



View all my reviews

Comments

  1. SandiJuly 3, 2016 at 7:32 AM

    Well, this will come as no surprise, but I don't think there should be books for certain groups of people. I'm an adult who reads from the YA shelf all the time because a good story is a good story no matter where it's shelved. I guess I'm just lending credence to the notion that girls will read anything. I see why publishers market books to boys or girls. They're trying to make money. Hopefully libraries can strike a balance between promoting books to the readers most likely to read them, and broadening readers' horizons.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. CorinnJuly 6, 2016 at 4:55 PM

      I feel like there are more good stories to be had on the YA shelf- though I may be a bit biased. Plus, most of what I've been reading comes from lists of books named excellent for one reason or another. I'm super excited to see what real-life YAs think at my new workplace! I'll certainly report back!

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Review: Red Queen

Image
Red Queen by Victoria Aveyard My rating: 5 of 5 stars "I grew up wondering if I'd have food for supper; now I'm standing in a place about to be eaten alive." -Mare. Mare is a Red. Red, as in the color of her blood. In Mare's world, there are Reds and Silvers. Silvers do have silver blood, but they also have special abilities or supernatural powers that make them the ruling class over the Reds. The Reds are the serving class, going to war for the Silvers in addition to being the workers who make the Silvers' clothing and exist generally to better the lives of the Silvers. They are nearly a slave class while the Silvers either are royals or seem to live like royals. Mare knows she is going to be sent off to war (she will be conscripted, as she calls it), like her older brothers. Her younger sister, Gisa, is an apprentice to a clothes-maker, so she will be able to avoid going to the war. Mare is envious of her sister and her safer path. Mare...
Read more

Will Grayson, Will Grayson

Image
Will Grayson, Will Grayson by John Green My rating: 4 of 5 stars "i don't know what freaks me out more- that i matter to him, or that he matters to me." -David Levithan Where to begin? I love this book. It is one of my absolute favorites. It's called Will Grayson, Will Grayson because it is about two different teenagers named Will Grayson. David Levithan authors the Naperville, IL Will Grayson. Naperville Will Grayson lives with his mother, is not affluent (he works to help pay the bills), does not have many friends, and was just betrayed by Maura, his closest friend. John Green authors North Shore Will Grayson, whose parents are doctors, who does what is expected of him, and who tries not to get noticed. He fails at trying not to get noticed simply by being best friends with Tiny Cooper. Tiny is best described in the words of North Shore Will Grayson: Tiny Cooper is not the world's gayest person, and he is not the world's largest person...
Read more

Rain Reign

Image
Rain Reign by Ann M. Martin My rating: 3 of 5 stars "My official diagnosis is high-functioning autism, which some people call Asperger's syndrome. (Do YOU have a diagnosis?)" -Ann M. Martin Meet Rose, main character and narrator, a 5th grader with high-functioning autism. Rose likes homonyms (Rose/rows), rules, and prime numbers. Rose lives with her father who doesn't always understand Rose and her autism. Rose has a dog she loves and cares for named Rain (reign). Rain gets lost after a hurricane, and Rose develops a plan to find her. Something unexpected happens on Rose's quest to return Rain home, and Rose learns she will have to accept change. Rain Reign is an enjoyable book, definitely for upper elementary and middle grades. Since the narrator is the main character/protagonist, the reader gets a window into the mind of someone who has autism. It's an interesting book I'm sure younger readers will connect with. View all my...
Read more